The passageway that separates our end of terrace cottage from the
neighbours is littered with the wings of moths. Most are from a common and
familiar species around here, the Large Yellow Underwing. In addition to the
moth wings there are tiny dark brown droppings, some on the floor and others
caught on the rough plaster walls. It is evident that something has been
perched on the walls feeding on moths caught above the garden; that ‘something’
is a Brown Long-eared Bat. Every now and then I catch sight of the bat, either
hawking around the trees or perched on the wall, mid-meal.
You might imagine that bats have it all their own way when it comes to
moths; that the bats simply fly around, detect and then catch the moths, thanks
largely to their echolocation system. Well, the arms race that is evolution has
equipped the moths with one or two tricks that can help them to evade capture.
Most bats use echolocation, through which a series of high frequency
sounds are produced by the bat, which then listens for the returning echo as
the pulse of sound bounces back off an object. Different bats use echolocation
in different ways but some general patterns can be seen, largely centred on the
habitat in which the bat is foraging. One group of bats that hunts out in the
open uses a technique known as aerial-hawking (this group includes the Common
Pipistrelle and the Noctule), while another group uses a technique known as
‘flutter-detecting’, which relies on the Doppler effect. A third group of bats,
whose members tend to glean food from the surface of leaves, adopts a different
approach.
Many moth species have specialized hearing organs which can detect the
echolocation calls made by bats from up to 30m away. Since most bats can only
detect moths present within 5m, this gives the moths time to turn away from the
approaching bat. If, however, the bat is much closer to the moth when it is
first detected, the moth will make a sudden and pronounced dive towards the
ground. A few moths respond to the calls by making clicking sounds of their own
which, when heard by the bat, cause it to turn away.
Such adaptations appear to give the moths an advantage so it is perhaps
unsurprising that, despite what you might think, moths usually only form a
small proportion of a typical bat’s diet (up to 40% in the case of the Brown
Long-eared Bat but as low as 5% in the case of the pipistrelles). Some bats do,
however, specialise on moths (e.g. Barbastelle) but these tend to take smaller
moths, which lack the anti-bat defence systems possessed by most larger moths.